2016 finalists for the Video Game Hall of Fame

http://www.worldvideogamehalloffame.org/2016-finalists



I'm assuming they're picking six from this list of fifteen:



Elite

Final Fantasy

GTA III

John Madden Football

Legend of Zelda

Minecraft

Nurburgring

Oregon Trail

Pokemon Red and Green

Sid Meier's Civilization

The Sims

Sonic the Hedgehog

Space Invaders

Street Fighter II

Tomb Raider
«1

Comments

  • Originally posted by: Tulpa



    Nurburgring

    The what what? I had to look this one up.  I remember there was a "game before night driver" but never remembered what it was called. 
  • Wow Nurburgring?!?! Interesting candidate. .. I wonder if inducting that game would result in the museum setting that game up for visitors to play? THAT would be awesome.



    .. As for the actual winners, I'm certain it will consist mostly of games I do not enjoy or care about, but are deserving of induction based on the criteria.
  • Never even heard of Nurburgring and I'm sure most people haven't either. The committee is already getting too cute for themselves. I've prety much soured on all hall of fame committees as 9/10 times they don't know what in the hell they are doing. Pretty sad.
  • If I'm picking 6 from that list:



    Final Fantasy

    Legend of Zelda

    Street Fighter II

    Oregon Trail

    Sonic the Hedgehog

    GTA III



    Honorable mention to Madden.
  • Is no Pokemon game in yet? If not, that's crazy and it should definitely get in this year.
  • Space Invaders

    Legend Of Zelda

    GTA III

    All games that had major cultural influence that helped to establish video gaming as a mainstream hobby.

    Madden and Pokémon are also up there, but I'm not so sure the specific games are what stood out, as much as the franchise.

    The rest of the field are great games, but to me excelled more within their genres respectively.
  • Originally posted by: mattbep



    Is no Pokemon game in yet? If not, that's crazy and it should definitely get in this year.



    There's only 6 games in it already.  Doom, Pac-man, Pong, Super MArio Bros, Tetris, and World of Warcraft. 
  • No love for Elite here?
  • I feel like minecraft hasn't earned it yet.



    My list matches Jones, except my honorable would be pokemon
  • Originally posted by: Ozzy_98

     
    Originally posted by: mattbep



    Is no Pokemon game in yet? If not, that's crazy and it should definitely get in this year.



    There's only 6 games in it already.  Doom, Pac-man, Pong, Super MArio Bros, Tetris, and World of Warcraft. 



    Whoops. Ok those are some pretty good first round picks. The only one I might exclude would be Doom, but that's just cause I haven't played it. Out of this year's list though, I think Pokemon should definitely be in. 
  • I'm not sure why The Sims is on there before SimCity. If I had to pick six off that list, I'd go with Final Fantasy, Legend of Zelda, Street Fighter II, Space Invaders, Madden and Sonic the Hedgehog.
  • After Sapce Invaders, Zelda, and Grand Theft Auto, I'd choose the following to round out my 6 inductees:

    Street Fighter II

    Sonic The Hedgehog

    Final Fantasy



    Street Fighter II helped to revitalize the arcade scene, and was a huge success when ported over to console



    Sonic led the charge of the Sega Genesis' push to dethrone Nintendo as the King of the console market. Sonic and the Genesis let fans know the console war had begun



    Final Fantasy helped turn based rpgs become popular outside of the pc. Nintendo games of the era tended not to be nearly as time consuming and vast in scope. Final Fantasy and Dragon Warrior/Quest, raised the bar for what gamers could/should expect on a home console.



    Honorable mentions to Civilization for being somewhat of a pioneer in its genre, and The Sims. Anyone who was into PC gaming around the turn of the Millennium, will remember how big of a phenomenon the Sims franchise was(as well as Rollercoaster Tycoon/Tycoon Series.



    That's my take on the 2016 field
  • Pokémon is getting in 110% the cultural impact is unquestionable.
  • I think it should be:
    • Pokemon Red and Green
    • Minecraft
    • Legend of Zelda
    • Sonic the Hedgehog
    • Final Fantasy
    • John Madden Football
    With honorable mentions to the Sims and Street Fighter II. Each of those six games have changed the gaming landscape in each region they were released in, and remain popular to this day. There are also plenty of knock-offs and impersonators for each of those franchises, which is a testament to how important they are.

     


  • These three games seem like locks:



    Legend of Zelda

    Space Invaders

    Street Fighter II



    Guess I'd take these as the final three:



    Civilization

    Final Fantasy

    Tomb Raider



    Really, Dragon Quest should be there instead of Final Fantasy. Pokemon has no business getting in before either of those.
  • I'd pick:



    Final Fantasy

    Legend of Zelda

    Oregon Trail

    Civilization

    Space Invaders

    Street Fighter II
  • Originally posted by: Philosoraptor

    I think it should be:
    • Pokemon Red and Green
    • Minecraft
    • Legend of Zelda
    • Sonic the Hedgehog
    • Final Fantasy
    • John Madden Football
    With honorable mentions to the Sims and Street Fighter II. Each of those six games have changed the gaming landscape in each region they were released in, and remain popular to this day. There are also plenty of knock-offs and impersonators for each of those franchises, which is a testament to how important they are.

     




    I would argue that GTA III fits your criteria as well. The amount of media attention that came after this game was released was incredible. Grand Theft Auto also made major strides in helping games to be accepted as works of art that shouldn't be censored. Imho

  • Originally posted by: Geester




    Originally posted by: Philosoraptor



    I think it should be:

    • Pokemon Red and Green

    • Minecraft

    • Legend of Zelda

    • Sonic the Hedgehog

    • Final Fantasy

    • John Madden Football
    With honorable mentions to the Sims and Street Fighter II. Each of those six games have changed the gaming landscape in each region they were released in, and remain popular to this day. There are also plenty of knock-offs and impersonators for each of those franchises, which is a testament to how important they are.

     



    I would argue that GTA III fits your criteria as well. The amount of media attention that came after this game was released was incredible. Grand Theft Auto also made major strides in helping games to be accepted as works of art that shouldn't be censored. Imho

    I personally am not a fan of the GTA franchie, but I think your point is 100% correct. I'll also say that GTA III did open world very well, and that franchise always has pushed the limits of that genre. It's certainly a franchise that deserves a place in the hall of fame.
  • Originally posted by: ToxieRules



    Pokémon is getting in 110% the cultural impact is unquestionable.



    The game helped spread anime across NA to the mainstream but people tend to forget that part, was pokemon the first anime to hit america? hell no but it was that one that set the western world on fire and dbz.

     
  • Originally posted by: zredgemz

    Originally posted by: ToxieRules



    Pokémon is getting in 110% the cultural impact is unquestionable.



    The game helped spread anime across NA to the mainstream but people tend to forget that part, was pokemon the first anime to hit america? hell no but it was that one that set the western world on fire and dbz.

     



    yeah and not to mention it is in the top 3 successful video video game franchises of all time with more units sold only second to Mario. It should get it...I would be very surprised if it doesn't.
  • Originally posted by: ToxieRules









    yeah and not to mention it is in the top 3 successful video video game franchises of all time with more units sold only second to Mario. It should get it...I would be very surprised if it doesn't.



    Pokemon the movie box-office sales record of five million opening week was not beat till the latest DBZ that just hit theaters a year ago. I wish i had the stats on how many gameboys were sold during that era but the new gameboy pocket came out around the same time. I really like some of these picks they did during this batch, i wonder how long till NWC ends up being voted on.

     
  • Am I the only one who thinks Minecraft shouldn't be in among these titles
  • Originally posted by: Double0seven



    Am I the only one who thinks Minecraft shouldn't be in among these titles

    Even though it's a newer franchise in comparison to the others, it's a huge deal and has had a lot of impact on the gameplay elements included in a number of newer titles and indie games. You don't necessarily need longevity to have a great impact, just look at Bo Jackson or the last two years Stephen Curry has had.  



     
  • Elite? Interesting....
  • Interesting picks. As much of a Final Fantasy fan I am, Dragon Quest should be in there first. And other RPGs before those two.

    I feel like half the time they are adding classics and pioneers that truly deserve to be there, and the other half of the time they are adding fads just because they were/are popular.
  • Originally posted by: cirellio

    I feel like half the time they are adding classics and pioneers that truly deserve to be there, and the other half of the time they are adding fads just because they were/are popular.



    Well, that's how most hall of fames work. It's "Hall of Fame," not "Hall of Greatness."

     
  • Minecraft...really? And they have The Sims but no Sim City? GTFO with this BS, this "hall of fame" has no credibility whatsoever.
  • Originally posted by: pegboy



    Minecraft...really? And they have The Sims but no Sim City? GTFO with this BS, this "hall of fame" has no credibility whatsoever.



    Finally, someone else agrees with me on this. If SimCity didn't get the entire Sim franchise going, The Sims wouldn't even exist.

     
  • Originally posted by: bearcat-doug

     
    Originally posted by: pegboy



    Minecraft...really? And they have The Sims but no Sim City? GTFO with this BS, this "hall of fame" has no credibility whatsoever.



    Finally, someone else agrees with me on this. If SimCity didn't get the entire Sim franchise going, The Sims wouldn't even exist.

     



    Yea, but you also have the "raid on bungeling bay" that you needed for sim city, yet it by itself wasn't too impressive.  And sims were just a rehash of david cranes "Little Computer People".



    Rather than just list games, they also need to list WHY; they kind of do on the page but not to any real degree.  Is the Sims nominated for being the best-selling pc game franchise ever?  Or for the open-endedness?  

     
Sign In or Register to comment.