I have no issue with your ability to look at edits, as I'm not lackadaisical enough to have to edit my posts. Even if so, I just double post like everyone else.
I agree with you fully Bronty, editing posts is basically the same thing. I'd just not want you to fall to that same level. It's a slippery slope that will make people doubt whether mods should be ALLOWED in these games. I know that this is a concern that others right here on NA have had in the past. Frankly it makes mods/admins look like "the other" when I'm sure all you really want is to be able to play games with the rest of us just like the rest of us. Your mod status shouldn't be cause for others to not want you to participate.
Now back to game things: MBC is IMO the perfect candidate for what I have been speaking to thus far - a quiet person who is not wholly inactive. As has been said, he jumps in, defends himself, disappears.
Again though, if we're going to vote someone for this, I say go all the way. You want to gamble, let's gamble. Cards on the table, all in.
Games are often fun until the moment someone decides to take advantage of a technicality to gain an edge.
Technically the rules say the GM can enlist mods to undo edits anyways
If Dra600n wants it done it should be from a mod not in the game. And if that one message is pulled we need to pull ALL the edited messages from this thread...just saying some other people have done it too and nothing was said.
I always felt all edited posts should be revealed. Simply because we DO have mods in these games and they have the option of obtaining info most of us don't.
I have no issue with them checking out what was said. I just think everyone should have that info too.
I also bet we'd have less edits if the real punishment was transparency.
I always felt all edited posts should be revealed. Simply because we DO have mods in these games and they have the option of obtaining info most of us don't.
I have no issue with them checking out what was said. I just think everyone should have that info too.
I also bet we'd have less edits if the real punishment was transparency.
I'm all for that. What you describe about breaking the rules accidentally on purpose is a regular occurrence. Every time there's an edit, we can get a mod in the game to post the history. I don't want to bother outside mods with it though. They have enough to do.
I think NED is town. I doubt Dragoon would give us such misleading info, we did just lose two VT one of which was the preist. If he did the town is pretty much screwed already, what kinda game would that be?
I also like lunching MBC because he's been larehely inaxtivebexcept when pushed, and because lunching him may tell us a little more about NED. He was pretty adamant NED must be town. And maybe NED is, he certainly took a big risk. His biggest defender at the time was MBC. Might mean nothing but it would be an interesting little sidebpoint to consider
Back to the discussion at hand, if you think MBC is hiding something to protect NED then why do you still think NED is town? Just curious as to this conclusion, because to me if I thought one was a wolf I'd think they both were. Or maybe MBC is the real seer so he knows NED is town? Or maybe they are both indys? Who knows I'm just shooting out ideas and am just trying to see how you came to your conclusion.
Why dont we wait to see if another note is given? If there is we can go from there. If mbc is town and and exposed the wolves would want him dead at night, if hes a townie and they planted the bote then they shouldnt target him at night. I say we leave him alone and go after someone else. Im gonna guess no note will be given
I also like lunching MBC because he's been larehely inaxtivebexcept when pushed, and because lunching him may tell us a little more about NED. He was pretty adamant NED must be town. And maybe NED is, he certainly took a big risk. His biggest defender at the time was MBC. Might mean nothing but it would be an interesting little sidebpoint to consider
Back to the discussion at hand, if you think MBC is hiding something to protect NED then why do you still think NED is town? Just curious as to this conclusion, because to me if I thought one was a wolf I'd think they both were. Or maybe MBC is the real seer so he knows NED is town? Or maybe they are both indys? Who knows I'm just shooting out ideas and am just trying to see how you came to your conclusion.
I'm not saying any of that just saying that yes if one is a wolf there's a decent chance the other is too. Meaning MBC is a good lynch candidate
Why dont we wait to see if another note is given? If there is we can go from there. If mbc is town and and exposed the wolves would want him dead at night, if hes a townie and they planted the bote then they shouldnt target him at night. I say we leave him alone and go after someone else. Im gonna guess no note will be given
This is actually my line of thinking as well and why I had no intention of voting MBC today
Why dont we wait to see if another note is given? If there is we can go from there. If mbc is town and and exposed the wolves would want him dead at night, if hes a townie and they planted the bote then they shouldnt target him at night. I say we leave him alone and go after someone else. Im gonna guess no note will be given
This is actually my line of thinking as well and why I had no intention of voting MBC today
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Why dont we wait to see if another note is given? If there is we can go from there. If mbc is town and and exposed the wolves would want him dead at night, if hes a townie and they planted the bote then they shouldnt target him at night. I say we leave him alone and go after someone else. Im gonna guess no note will be given
This is actually my line of thinking as well and why I had no intention of voting MBC today
Can you guys explain your thought process a bit more. How and when did MBC expose a wolf? From what I gathered, all the note said was "MBC was not seen last night". Why is no one talking more about what this means and why is no one using it as apart of their argument for why MBC should or shouldn't get voted.
NED, you are crazy if you think town will sit by and wait for another note.
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Your right we do have a whole day left. Maybe some of the quiets will speak up. Until then :
Honestly, I'm about to just end this round and let someone else either redo it or move onto the next round.
Bronty shouldn't be using his mod powers to his advantage. Yes, nobody should be editing posts, sometimes shit happens, but that's crossing the line IMO. This is supposed to be a fun game, but now it's just become ridiculous.
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question.
I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge.
Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question. I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge. Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
I wouldn't say I "agree with Bronty". I simply wanted to see the cloak go to a person of town's choosing, rather than being grabbed up by someone at the last minute. I'd have LOVED if we could make it a totally random thing, but as I explained on Day 2, there was too much risk of someone popping in and getting the cloak with ease.
Remember, ELEVEN people voted for him to get it. It was a majority vote by far, based on very little information.
As for you, please re-read the things I have said directly to you in the game. I am confident that you are town.
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question. I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge. Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
I wouldn't say I "agree with Bronty". I simply wanted to see the cloak go to a person of town's choosing, rather than being grabbed up by someone at the last minute. I'd have LOVED if we could make it a totally random thing, but as I explained on Day 2, there was too much risk of someone popping in and getting the cloak with ease.
Remember, ELEVEN people voted for him to get it. It was a majority vote by far, based on very little information.
As for you, please re-read the things I have said directly to you in the game. I am confident that you are town.
You have good judgement, but Im still unsure about you Gloves. Its good that your not at my throat for questioning you. In that past feuds between two VT have crippled towns chances of nailing a wolf.
I wouldn't say I "agree with Bronty". I simply wanted to see the cloak go to a person of town's choosing, rather than being grabbed up by someone at the last minute. I'd have LOVED if we could make it a totally random thing, but as I explained on Day 2, there was too much risk of someone popping in and getting the cloak with ease.
Remember, ELEVEN people voted for him to get it. It was a majority vote by far, based on very little information.
As for you, please re-read the things I have said directly to you in the game. I am confident that you are town.
You have good judgement, but Im still unsure about you Gloves. Its good that your not at my throat for questioning you. In that past feuds between two VT have crippled towns chances of nailing a wolf.
I don't want to feud. I am with you, and as I've said before, we need to be a solid team as town to have a chance. That is #1. We can disagree, certainly, but we need to work together.
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question. I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge. Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
I literally just disagreed with him but ok.
Ya, I see now that you did while I was typing. Hmmm, coincidence?
**VOTE PuppyWaffles
If Im wrong about you Puppy, sorry. Ill turn my attention to Brock and Wasg.
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question. I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge. Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
At least 1 out of 6 people? Yeah, probably. Maybe even 2 of them
Comments
I agree with you fully Bronty, editing posts is basically the same thing. I'd just not want you to fall to that same level. It's a slippery slope that will make people doubt whether mods should be ALLOWED in these games. I know that this is a concern that others right here on NA have had in the past. Frankly it makes mods/admins look like "the other" when I'm sure all you really want is to be able to play games with the rest of us just like the rest of us. Your mod status shouldn't be cause for others to not want you to participate.
Again though, if we're going to vote someone for this, I say go all the way. You want to gamble, let's gamble. Cards on the table, all in.
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
Games are often fun until the moment someone decides to take advantage of a technicality to gain an edge.
Technically the rules say the GM can enlist mods to undo edits anyways
If Dra600n wants it done it should be from a mod not in the game. And if that one message is pulled we need to pull ALL the edited messages from this thread...just saying some other people have done it too and nothing was said.
No argument there. Dra600n?
I have no issue with them checking out what was said. I just think everyone should have that info too.
I also bet we'd have less edits if the real punishment was transparency.
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
I always felt all edited posts should be revealed. Simply because we DO have mods in these games and they have the option of obtaining info most of us don't.
I have no issue with them checking out what was said. I just think everyone should have that info too.
I also bet we'd have less edits if the real punishment was transparency.
I'm all for that. What you describe about breaking the rules accidentally on purpose is a regular occurrence. Every time there's an edit, we can get a mod in the game to post the history. I don't want to bother outside mods with it though. They have enough to do.
I think NED is town. I doubt Dragoon would give us such misleading info, we did just lose two VT one of which was the preist. If he did the town is pretty much screwed already, what kinda game would that be?
I also like lunching MBC because he's been larehely inaxtivebexcept when pushed, and because lunching him may tell us a little more about NED. He was pretty adamant NED must be town. And maybe NED is, he certainly took a big risk. His biggest defender at the time was MBC. Might mean nothing but it would be an interesting little sidebpoint to consider
Back to the discussion at hand, if you think MBC is hiding something to protect NED then why do you still think NED is town? Just curious as to this conclusion, because to me if I thought one was a wolf I'd think they both were. Or maybe MBC is the real seer so he knows NED is town? Or maybe they are both indys? Who knows I'm just shooting out ideas and am just trying to see how you came to your conclusion.
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
I also like lunching MBC because he's been larehely inaxtivebexcept when pushed, and because lunching him may tell us a little more about NED. He was pretty adamant NED must be town. And maybe NED is, he certainly took a big risk. His biggest defender at the time was MBC. Might mean nothing but it would be an interesting little sidebpoint to consider
Back to the discussion at hand, if you think MBC is hiding something to protect NED then why do you still think NED is town? Just curious as to this conclusion, because to me if I thought one was a wolf I'd think they both were. Or maybe MBC is the real seer so he knows NED is town? Or maybe they are both indys? Who knows I'm just shooting out ideas and am just trying to see how you came to your conclusion.
I'm not saying any of that just saying that yes if one is a wolf there's a decent chance the other is too. Meaning MBC is a good lynch candidate
Why dont we wait to see if another note is given? If there is we can go from there. If mbc is town and and exposed the wolves would want him dead at night, if hes a townie and they planted the bote then they shouldnt target him at night. I say we leave him alone and go after someone else. Im gonna guess no note will be given
This is actually my line of thinking as well and why I had no intention of voting MBC today
Why dont we wait to see if another note is given? If there is we can go from there. If mbc is town and and exposed the wolves would want him dead at night, if hes a townie and they planted the bote then they shouldnt target him at night. I say we leave him alone and go after someone else. Im gonna guess no note will be given
This is actually my line of thinking as well and why I had no intention of voting MBC today
So who would you rather vote for today then?
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Why dont we wait to see if another note is given? If there is we can go from there. If mbc is town and and exposed the wolves would want him dead at night, if hes a townie and they planted the bote then they shouldnt target him at night. I say we leave him alone and go after someone else. Im gonna guess no note will be given
This is actually my line of thinking as well and why I had no intention of voting MBC today
Can you guys explain your thought process a bit more. How and when did MBC expose a wolf? From what I gathered, all the note said was "MBC was not seen last night". Why is no one talking more about what this means and why is no one using it as apart of their argument for why MBC should or shouldn't get voted.
NED, you are crazy if you think town will sit by and wait for another note.
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Your right we do have a whole day left. Maybe some of the quiets will speak up. Until then :
**UNVOTE: NESfreak
Bronty shouldn't be using his mod powers to his advantage. Yes, nobody should be editing posts, sometimes shit happens, but that's crossing the line IMO. This is supposed to be a fun game, but now it's just become ridiculous.
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question.
I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge.
Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
Originally posted by: NESfanatic
Im having fun dragoon we need a little more common sense in the game i guess
At least one person is. The game has been ruined for a few people now, myself included.
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question. I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge. Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
I wouldn't say I "agree with Bronty". I simply wanted to see the cloak go to a person of town's choosing, rather than being grabbed up by someone at the last minute. I'd have LOVED if we could make it a totally random thing, but as I explained on Day 2, there was too much risk of someone popping in and getting the cloak with ease.
Remember, ELEVEN people voted for him to get it. It was a majority vote by far, based on very little information.
As for you, please re-read the things I have said directly to you in the game. I am confident that you are town.
Im having fun dragoon we need a little more common sense in the game i guess
At least one person is. The game has been ruined for a few people now, myself included.
I'm still having fun too! Don't let a few bad noodles ruin the spaghetti!
Im having fun dragoon we need a little more common sense in the game i guess
At least one person is. The game has been ruined for a few people now, myself included.
I'm still having fun too! Don't let a few bad noodles ruin the spaghetti!
I like spaghetti
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question. I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge. Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
I literally just disagreed with him but ok.
I wouldn't say I "agree with Bronty". I simply wanted to see the cloak go to a person of town's choosing, rather than being grabbed up by someone at the last minute. I'd have LOVED if we could make it a totally random thing, but as I explained on Day 2, there was too much risk of someone popping in and getting the cloak with ease.
Remember, ELEVEN people voted for him to get it. It was a majority vote by far, based on very little information.
As for you, please re-read the things I have said directly to you in the game. I am confident that you are town.
You have good judgement, but Im still unsure about you Gloves. Its good that your not at my throat for questioning you. In that past feuds between two VT have crippled towns chances of nailing a wolf.
I wouldn't say I "agree with Bronty". I simply wanted to see the cloak go to a person of town's choosing, rather than being grabbed up by someone at the last minute. I'd have LOVED if we could make it a totally random thing, but as I explained on Day 2, there was too much risk of someone popping in and getting the cloak with ease.
Remember, ELEVEN people voted for him to get it. It was a majority vote by far, based on very little information.
As for you, please re-read the things I have said directly to you in the game. I am confident that you are town.
You have good judgement, but Im still unsure about you Gloves. Its good that your not at my throat for questioning you. In that past feuds between two VT have crippled towns chances of nailing a wolf.
I don't want to feud. I am with you, and as I've said before, we need to be a solid team as town to have a chance. That is #1. We can disagree, certainly, but we need to work together.
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question. I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge. Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
I literally just disagreed with him but ok.
Ya, I see now that you did while I was typing. Hmmm, coincidence?
**VOTE PuppyWaffles
If Im wrong about you Puppy, sorry. Ill turn my attention to Brock and Wasg.
**VOTE: MasterBigCat
I've been saying I want to lynch off some quiets, and there is a lot of evidence piling up here.
If anyone feels theres a better candidate, speak up and give some reasons. We can't keep going around in circles
We still have a day and a half. I will be proposing an active player who makes continuous vague and agreeable posts after I identify who best fit that mold
Puppy, limbo, and gloves all seem to agree with Bronty. Thats how he got the cloak so easily and with little question. I also think you brock and wasg always seem to see eye to eye, and have some sort of knowledge. Guarenteed at least one of these playas is a wolf. Town should not be taking sides and backing each other with such confidence with nothing to go on at this point. All we know is that Dragoons story confermed NED is VT, I think thats his way of cutting town a break. I'm concerned why anyone would think/vote otherwise at this point.
At least 1 out of 6 people? Yeah, probably. Maybe even 2 of them