Music Debate II: Lady Gaga





Ratings key:

10 - One of your very favorite artists of all time.

9 - Killer fucking band.  Or artist.

8 - Great sound, great songs, great albums.

7 - Very good, but not quite great.

6 - Pretty good.  More than a few songs you like.  You'd entertain the thought of seeing them live if they were in the area.  Or still alive.

5 - They're okay, but maybe not something you'll go out of your way to listen to.

4 - Meh.  There may be a song or two, or an album that you dig, but you'd rather listen to other stuff.

3 - Not very good.  You will more likely than not turn the station if they come on the radio.

2 - Not your cup of tea at all.  Some people like this, but you are not one of them.

1 - Horrible in every way.

0 - In the running for worst artist/musician of all time.  You would rather take a cheese grater to your face than listen to this.



























Current Standings:

5.00 - Lady Gaga

4.33 - Linkin Park
«1

Comments

  • I don't listen to her but my wife loves her. I respect her talent and think she's a very driven woman but not my cup of tea in terms of music making it a tough rank. I feel she has a pretty positive influence and has accomplished more than most pop artists these days.
  • Her music sucks. As a singer, she's decent. Her lyrics aren't good, music isn't good, and I grew sick of the shock factor antics that she copied from others.
  • right around a 6, only because i like her more serious approach now.
  • For what she does she's talented but in my opinion pop music is just garbage. I'll give her a few extra points because she's good at what she does but I can't get past how bad pop music is.
  • Muh muh muh muhhhh!
  • She's really very talented. You can find video of her doing music other than pop and she just kills. She just decided she wanted to be commercially successful in the music business.



    She and her producer decided to just make good dance songs, as that's the most surefire way to make a lot of money.
  • Better than Linkin Park, still not gangsta though!
  • Originally posted by: Tulpa



    She's really very talented. You can find video of her doing music other than pop and she just kills. She just decided she wanted to be commercially successful in the music business.



    She and her producer decided to just make good dance songs, as that's the most surefire way to make a lot of money.

    I agree.  I don't like all of her super pop stuff, but she is definitely talented.  



    If you watch her live performance of "edge of glory" [not the up-beat dance version, but the slower one], it is pretty great IMO.



    For example:









     
  • Once again, 2.
  • Originally posted by: sadikyo

     
    Originally posted by: Tulpa



    She's really very talented. You can find video of her doing music other than pop and she just kills. She just decided she wanted to be commercially successful in the music business.



    She and her producer decided to just make good dance songs, as that's the most surefire way to make a lot of money.

    I agree.  I don't like all of her super pop stuff, but she is definitely talented.  



    If you watch her live performance of "edge of glory" [not the up-beat dance version, but the slower one], it is pretty great IMO.



    For example:



     

    allowfullscreen="" frameborder="0" height="280" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/r0X7PodqDSE" width="500">>










     





    Yea, ive always liked the songs she puts out (having a teen daughter has pushed me into listening to stuff i normall wouldnt), but this video is just pure, raw, talent. I dont know of any other singer that has the talent she does. It doesnt matter the song, if she sings it shell put all of herself into it and it will be great. 
  • She no Fiona but still a great singer imo
  • Originally posted by: skinnygrinny



    She no Fiona but still a great singer imo

    Nobody is Fiona, if it ain't Fiona Apple I don't even give a shit.

     
  • 6/10 She aaight. Liked her better when she was weird. Way better than that Fiona chick at any rate.
  • Originally posted by: JamesRobot



    6/10 She aaight. Liked her better when she was weird. Way better than that Fiona chick at any rate.

     



     
  • Originally posted by: KlaklonxieShrools

    Originally posted by: JamesRobot



    6/10 She aaight. Liked her better when she was weird. Way better than that Fiona chick at any rate.

     



     
    Go listen to some Tori Amos while you're at it.
  • Originally posted by: JamesRobot

     
    Originally posted by: KlaklonxieShrools

     
    Originally posted by: JamesRobot



    6/10 She aaight. Liked her better when she was weird. Way better than that Fiona chick at any rate.

     



     

    Go listen to some Tori Amos while you're at it.

    Rotfl!!!
  • Originally posted by: skinnygrinny

     
    Originally posted by: JamesRobot

     
    Originally posted by: KlaklonxieShrools

     
    Originally posted by: JamesRobot



    6/10 She aaight. Liked her better when she was weird. Way better than that Fiona chick at any rate.

     



     

    Go listen to some Tori Amos while you're at it.

    Rotfl!!!
  • is this real life
  • Originally posted by: KlaklonxieShrools

     
    Originally posted by: skinnygrinny



    She no Fiona but still a great singer imo

    Nobody is Fiona, if it ain't Fiona Apple I don't even give a shit.

     

    No not baby anymore

    if I need you I’ll just use your simple name..







     
  • Originally posted by: MSC



    is this real life



    I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia. 



    There is another member of NA with the user name “MBD” and that is similar to yours. 

     
  • Originally posted by: skinnygrinny

     
    Originally posted by: MSC



    is this real life



    I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia. 



    There is another member of NA with the user name “MBD” and that is similar to yours. 

     





    cool fact 

    but im not sure what's the meaning of  "I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia" 
  • Originally posted by: MSC

     
    Originally posted by: skinnygrinny

     
    Originally posted by: MSC



    is this real life



    I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia. 



    There is another member of NA with the user name “MBD” and that is similar to yours. 

     





    cool fact 

    but im not sure what's the meaning of  "I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia" 



    Lol



    because of paranoia shouldn’t be in quotes 

     
  • Originally posted by: MSC

     
    Originally posted by: skinnygrinny

     
    Originally posted by: MSC



    is this real life



    I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia. 



    There is another member of NA with the user name “MBD” and that is similar to yours. 

     





    cool fact 

    but im not sure what's the meaning of  "I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia" 



    It's not you.  He's a lunatic.

     
  • Originally posted by: Brock Landers

     
    Originally posted by: MSC

     
    Originally posted by: skinnygrinny

     
    Originally posted by: MSC



    is this real life



    I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia. 



    There is another member of NA with the user name “MBD” and that is similar to yours. 

     





    cool fact 

    but im not sure what's the meaning of  "I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia" 



    It's not you.  He's a lunatic.

     



    Ah. Ye ole lunaticus. Yes, of the moon for certain.

     
  • Originally posted by: skinnygrinny

     
    Originally posted by: Brock Landers

     
    Originally posted by: MSC

     
    Originally posted by: skinnygrinny

     
    Originally posted by: MSC



    is this real life



    I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia. 



    There is another member of NA with the user name “MBD” and that is similar to yours. 

     





    cool fact 

    but im not sure what's the meaning of  "I don’t like to tell people “see ya tomorrow” because of paranoia" 



    It's not you.  He's a lunatic.

     



    Ah. Ye ole lunaticus. Yes, of the moon for certain.

     





    im out  
  • 2/10



    Dont care for it. Some songs are catchy in a way where i get why people like it. Well , why girls might like it.



    Factoid, girl i went to grade school with . Her husband was a music producer on the star is born soundtrack which features lady gaga. Thought that was neat. One of the songs he worked on was nominated for awards so i guess it was well done. I assume its the song in that last video posted.
  • Originally posted by: quest4nes



    2/10



    Dont care for it. Some songs are catchy in a way where i get why people like it. Well , why girls might like it.



    Factoid, girl i went to grade school with . Her husband was a music producer on the star is born soundtrack which features lady gaga. Thought that was neat. One of the songs he worked on was nominated for awards so i guess it was well done. I assume its the song in that last video posted.



    One of these dudes?





     
  • I voted before I read the rules (10).... but I still think she's awesome.



    8-9, leaning towards 9 for me. I loves me some Lady Gaga.
  • Originally posted by: Brock Landers

     
    Originally posted by: quest4nes



    2/10



    Dont care for it. Some songs are catchy in a way where i get why people like it. Well , why girls might like it.



    Factoid, girl i went to grade school with . Her husband was a music producer on the star is born soundtrack which features lady gaga. Thought that was neat. One of the songs he worked on was nominated for awards so i guess it was well done. I assume its the song in that last video posted.



    One of these dudes?





     



    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Star_Is_Born_(2018_soundtrack)



    No, but its ben rice. On the far right he is on the list of producers . I think the guys she took on stage were writers as well as producers

     
  • Playing nice this time . Gave it a 10/10. She’s a total entrepreneur, and tho I don’t listen to her music, if you don’t respect lady Gaga, you probably don’t respect a lot of talent.imo
Sign In or Register to comment.