By CIB rarity and assuming low-end collector quality (8/10 condition), my top 10:
1. Stadium Events (R10/$10,000+) 2. 6-in-1 Myriad (R10/$2500-$3500) 3. Flintstones: Surprise at Dinosaur Peak (R9/$1000-$1200) 4. Hot Slots (R9/$1000-$1200) 5. Peek-a-Boo Poker (R9/$1000) 6. Bubble Bath Babes (R9/$1000) 7. Cheetahmen II (R9/$700) 8. 6-in-1 Caltron (we'll assume black back label, since it's the more common variant, versus the royal blue back label (i.e. not the one Robe24 has been selling); R9/$800 w/questionnaire) 9. Chubby Cherub (cart is fairly common, btw; R9/$400) 10. Donkey Kong Jr. Math (cart is fairly common; R9/$400)
Other rarer CIBs, in order, 11-20:
11. Sqoon (R9/$175) 12. Athletic World (Family Fun Fitness) (cart is fairly common; R9/$300) 13. Little Samson (R8/$250) 14. Secret Scout (R8/$200) 15. Mario's Time Machine (R8/$100) 16. Pro Sport Hockey (R8/$150) 17. Panic Restaurant (R8/$125) 18. Bonk's Adventure (R8/$200) 19. Color a Dinosaur (R8/$150) 20. Power Blade 2 (R8/$125)
Bubble Bobble Part 2 is significantly further down the list for rarity (it's on the low end of R7, I think), but its popularity pushes its price up into the top 12 or 15.
tuxedocivic: If you don't need it, I'll give you $100 US for it. Or $40 for the manual, either/or .
You're missing Stack-Up and big box Gyromite on your other rare CIB list.
By CIB rarity and assuming low-end collector quality (8/10 condition), my top 10:
1. Stadium Events (R10/$10,000+) 2. 6-in-1 Myriad (R10/$2500-$3500) 3. Flintstones: Surprise at Dinosaur Peak (R9/$1000-$1200) 4. Hot Slots (R9/$1000-$1200) 5. Peek-a-Boo Poker (R9/$1000) 6. Bubble Bath Babes (R9/$1000) 7. Cheetahmen II (R9/$700) 8. 6-in-1 Caltron (we'll assume black back label, since it's the more common variant, versus the royal blue back label (i.e. not the one Robe24 has been selling); R9/$800 w/questionnaire) 9. Chubby Cherub (cart is fairly common, btw; R9/$400) 10. Donkey Kong Jr. Math (cart is fairly common; R9/$400)
Other rarer CIBs, in order, 11-20:
11. Sqoon (R9/$175) 12. Athletic World (Family Fun Fitness) (cart is fairly common; R9/$300) 13. Little Samson (R8/$250) 14. Secret Scout (R8/$200) 15. Mario's Time Machine (R8/$100) 16. Pro Sport Hockey (R8/$150) 17. Panic Restaurant (R8/$125) 18. Bonk's Adventure (R8/$200) 19. Color a Dinosaur (R8/$150) 20. Power Blade 2 (R8/$125)
Bubble Bobble Part 2 is significantly further down the list for rarity (it's on the low end of R7, I think), but its popularity pushes its price up into the top 12 or 15.
tuxedocivic: If you don't need it, I'll give you $100 US for it. Or $40 for the manual, either/or .
You're missing Stack-Up and big box Gyromite on your other rare CIB list.
I wouldn't include Stack Up on a list of rare NES games. It's expensive, but at any given time, there's a complete one on eBay.
I did seem to forget big-box Gyromite...I'd say insert it at #16 and call it R8/$300, and push the current #16-#20 down 1 (making them #17-#21). Snow Brothers would probably be somewhere in the #22-#24 range, if it wasn't #22, and I'd put that in at R8/$140.
Edit: Arseface is correct...Stack-Up is rare, but not quite top 25 (though it may be top 25 in value).
Comments
By CIB rarity and assuming low-end collector quality (8/10 condition), my top 10:
1. Stadium Events (R10/$10,000+)
2. 6-in-1 Myriad (R10/$2500-$3500)
3. Flintstones: Surprise at Dinosaur Peak (R9/$1000-$1200)
4. Hot Slots (R9/$1000-$1200)
5. Peek-a-Boo Poker (R9/$1000)
6. Bubble Bath Babes (R9/$1000)
7. Cheetahmen II (R9/$700)
8. 6-in-1 Caltron (we'll assume black back label, since it's the more common variant, versus the royal blue back label (i.e. not the one Robe24 has been selling); R9/$800 w/questionnaire)
9. Chubby Cherub (cart is fairly common, btw; R9/$400)
10. Donkey Kong Jr. Math (cart is fairly common; R9/$400)
Other rarer CIBs, in order, 11-20:
11. Sqoon (R9/$175)
12. Athletic World (Family Fun Fitness) (cart is fairly common; R9/$300)
13. Little Samson (R8/$250)
14. Secret Scout (R8/$200)
15. Mario's Time Machine (R8/$100)
16. Pro Sport Hockey (R8/$150)
17. Panic Restaurant (R8/$125)
18. Bonk's Adventure (R8/$200)
19. Color a Dinosaur (R8/$150)
20. Power Blade 2 (R8/$125)
Bubble Bobble Part 2 is significantly further down the list for rarity (it's on the low end of R7, I think), but its popularity pushes its price up into the top 12 or 15.
tuxedocivic: If you don't need it, I'll give you $100 US for it. Or $40 for the manual, either/or
You're missing Stack-Up and big box Gyromite on your other rare CIB list.
By CIB rarity and assuming low-end collector quality (8/10 condition), my top 10:
1. Stadium Events (R10/$10,000+)
2. 6-in-1 Myriad (R10/$2500-$3500)
3. Flintstones: Surprise at Dinosaur Peak (R9/$1000-$1200)
4. Hot Slots (R9/$1000-$1200)
5. Peek-a-Boo Poker (R9/$1000)
6. Bubble Bath Babes (R9/$1000)
7. Cheetahmen II (R9/$700)
8. 6-in-1 Caltron (we'll assume black back label, since it's the more common variant, versus the royal blue back label (i.e. not the one Robe24 has been selling); R9/$800 w/questionnaire)
9. Chubby Cherub (cart is fairly common, btw; R9/$400)
10. Donkey Kong Jr. Math (cart is fairly common; R9/$400)
Other rarer CIBs, in order, 11-20:
11. Sqoon (R9/$175)
12. Athletic World (Family Fun Fitness) (cart is fairly common; R9/$300)
13. Little Samson (R8/$250)
14. Secret Scout (R8/$200)
15. Mario's Time Machine (R8/$100)
16. Pro Sport Hockey (R8/$150)
17. Panic Restaurant (R8/$125)
18. Bonk's Adventure (R8/$200)
19. Color a Dinosaur (R8/$150)
20. Power Blade 2 (R8/$125)
Bubble Bobble Part 2 is significantly further down the list for rarity (it's on the low end of R7, I think), but its popularity pushes its price up into the top 12 or 15.
tuxedocivic: If you don't need it, I'll give you $100 US for it. Or $40 for the manual, either/or
You're missing Stack-Up and big box Gyromite on your other rare CIB list.
I wouldn't include Stack Up on a list of rare NES games. It's expensive, but at any given time, there's a complete one on eBay.
Edit: Arseface is correct...Stack-Up is rare, but not quite top 25 (though it may be top 25 in value).