What's the worst trade you've ever made?

About a year ago, I got a rare NES game called Bandit Kings of Ancient China, which I then foolishly traded for a pricy, but common game, Mega Man 5 (and a Dogbone Controller).



As you'd might expect, Mega Man 5 is dropping, Bandit Kings is rising, which represents a classic mistake of trading a rare game for an overpriced common game.



What was YOUR worst trade ever?
«13

Comments

  • Can't think of anything right now other then the obligatory stack of games to GameStop for pocket change. I only started trading recently on here and so far it's been pretty even
  • Originally posted by: BertBerryCrunch



    Can't think of anything right now other then the obligatory stack of games to GameStop for pocket change.

    This is probably the most popular answer



     
  • Originally posted by: TWarwick07

    Originally posted by: BertBerryCrunch



    Can't think of anything right now other then the obligatory stack of games to GameStop for pocket change.

    This is probably the most popular answer



     



    yeah it was only GameCube and Xbox games for me luckily. And I at least had the foresight to keep the first party Nintendo games. So overall not a big loss 
  • I had just got a PS1 for Christmas and decided to trade in my SNES for trade credit at a local gaming store. They gave me a measly $5 for it and although my parents urged me not to, I traded it. If my kid was going to do that I would give him the $5 in exchange for the system and just put it in storage. When you are 6 years old and have little to no understanding of money, you make stupid decisions just like this one.
  • Years ago I had an extra Gamecube that I traded for a Sega Genesis since I never had one. I got hosed....

  • Originally posted by: Jonny_Blades



    I had just got a PS1 for Christmas and decided to trade in my SNES for trade credit at a local gaming store. They gave me a measly $5 for it and although my parents urged me not to, I traded it. If my kid was going to do that I would give him the $5 in exchange for the system and just put it in storage. When you are 6 years old and have little to no understanding of money, you make stupid decisions just like this one.





    That is actually quite sad, though on the flipside your parents did you a justice with a great life lesson. 
  • Originally posted by: Katchii


    Originally posted by: Jonny_Blades



    I had just got a PS1 for Christmas and decided to trade in my SNES for trade credit at a local gaming store. They gave me a measly $5 for it and although my parents urged me not to, I traded it. If my kid was going to do that I would give him the $5 in exchange for the system and just put it in storage. When you are 6 years old and have little to no understanding of money, you make stupid decisions just like this one.





    That is actually quite sad, though on the flipside your parents did you a justice with a great life lesson. 





    That is true. But I was only 6 and at the time didn't care about anything other what I had just got for Christmas. But I have a snes again now and way more games than I ever had growing up so I can't complain too much  
  • When I was in college I desperately wanted a Gamecube because I thought Starfox Adventures looked amazing. I traded my entire PS1 collection(of Mostly RPG's to Gamestop, along with many of the DC games I didn't play often. I also traded some of the NES games that I thought I would never play again. I used to have the receipt, I got around $0.25-$0.50 for most of the games, and ended up paying most of the cost out of pocket. As I was doing the trade, one of the empoyees came up and told me that the Games I was trading were pretty uncommon, and I should hold onto them instead of trading them for quarters apiece, the manager that was ringing me up told me that it was not true, and stupidly I believed him. As I was walking out the door I heard the manager tell him that he was going to buy most of my games, and thatX-Com was his, and that It was going for $75 on ebay. That was when I decided to stop trading stuff to Gamestop.



    I ran into trouble with that manager later when I preordered TLOZ: Windwaker. He told me that they were out of the promo Ocarina of Time discs that they were supposed to give out with preorders. A guy in one of my college classes told me that the manager gave all the preorder goodies to people that he was trying to be friends with. I ended up talking to the manager at the other GameStop in town, he gave me a disc, and I'm pretty sure that the guy got fired because I never saw him there again.



    When I was a kid I always played NES at my grandma's, so when I moved 8 hours away at 17(2001), I bought my first NES, along with some games at a local store in my new town, one of those games was Bubble Bobble 2 for $2, I later traded that game at Gamecrazy for next to nothing towards Capcom vs SNK for Xbox. This was when GameCrazy was selling their NES games for $1-$2. I stopped in the next week because my copy of Mario 3 was glitching and my roommate and I were trying to beat it. the guy working the counter said they were out of stock, asked me if I played much NES, and I told him that I had traded off all of the games except the ones I had good memories of as a kid, and the only reason I was buying the game was because my copy was acting up. He told me that he was a NES collector, and that someone had traded in a copy of a $50 game, and he got it for $.50. I asked him what it was, and he said Bubble Bobble 2. He also told me that he picked up tons of games at garage sales, and that I may be able to find a copy of Mario 3 at one. That was when I started going to garage sales more often, at first It was to get the rest the games I had played as a kid, and secondly to get back all the money I had lost trading in games.
  • Couple years ago traded a loose Ghoul Patrol for Super Smash Melee CIB. At the time Ghoul Patrol was a little over half it's current value but definitely on the rise. I had a spare copy and didn't own Smash Melee yet, plus it was trade with a member of the "outer circle" so it went to a good home. Thats about as bad as it gets though. I don't really do game stores so i have no horror stories of getting pennies for games.



    I'm sure others will have some cringe-worthy examples to follow.
  • Originally posted by: ULTRACASTLE00



    About a year ago, I got a rare NES game called Bandit Kings of Ancient China, which I then foolishly traded for a pricy, but common game, Mega Man 5 (and a Dogbone Controller).



    As you'd might expect, Mega Man 5 is dropping, Bandit Kings is rising, which represents a classic mistake of trading a rare game for an overpriced common game.



    What was YOUR worst trade ever?

    That isn't a bad trade at all. MM5 + a dogbone is about right. Plus, you'd probably never play BK, and MM5 is totally playable.



    If you want to make yourself feel better, buy this nice looking box and folded manual for 70. Not a bad deal:

    http://www.ebay.com/itm/Bandit-Kings-of-Ancient-China-BOX-AND-MANUAL-ONLY-NES-Nintendo-/182298756458



    I once traded a Don Mattingly rookie card for an '87 Spike Owen, because it was the last Red Sox player I needed for my team set. Doh.









     
  • Basically anything I "traded" into Software Etc. and Electronics Boutique back in the day...
  • Final Fight Guy for Mario RPG.

    Action 52 for Contra Force.

    Master system and 19 games (including a CIB Moonwalker) for a PS1.

    Mega Man 5 for Little Mermaid (no regrets on that one though, in the same position I'd do the same trade again).



    In hindsight those are probably the "worst" ones I've done.
  • Back in 2000 I had bought a house and had a small child. I started getting back into video games. I didn't like trading in games to local stores or EB games. I started trading online at Gametz. A lot of my first trades if you look at them now are incredibly lopsided. I traded a CIB Ninja Gaiden Trilogy Snes for a cart only Super Robot Wars EX for the Super Famicom. Mind you I only paid $25 Canadian for the Ninja Gaiden Trilogy and SFC games were pretty uncommon at the time so I was happy with the trade. Another trade I made was with a local collector. I really wanted his mint CIB Dragonstrike Nes. Not that I liked the game that much but I loved the artwork on the box lol. I traded him a CIB Mega Man 6, Nes cleaning kit CIB, Nobunaga's amibition cart only and L'Empereur cart only. I have several more doozies lol!
  • In response to TENGEN, I found a nice looking box, manual and game for $125   Not sure why nobody grabbed it beforehand. Pretty sure it was a relisting.
  • Originally posted by: ULTRACASTLE00



    About a year ago, I got a rare NES game called Bandit Kings of Ancient China, which I then foolishly traded for a pricy, but common game, Mega Man 5 (and a Dogbone Controller).



    As you'd might expect, Mega Man 5 is dropping, Bandit Kings is rising, which represents a classic mistake of trading a rare game for an overpriced common game.



    What was YOUR worst trade ever?



    Yeah, but Mega Man 5 is the far more entertaining game, in my opinion and I don't think many would disagree, unless you really dislike Mega Man. At least you have a really fun game in your collection as opposed to a mediocre, rare turd.

     
  • Bandit King of Ancient China is an excellent Koei game, it isn't just a 'rare turd'.
  • Yeah, I don't think you can compare gameplay. Mega Man might have more widespread appeal, but that doesn't mean Bandit Kings is a bad game.
  • Worst in that I was unable to predict the future, MUSHA for battletoads/double dragon



    worst that I still think about with regret from time to time, pristine CIB model one sega cd with CIB final fight and Vay for symphony of the night and a memory card. Still mad thinking about it.
  • The trend recently is that Mega Man 5 has fallen while the other game has gone up. Also, fyi, I did not get rid of Mega Man 5.
  • Originally posted by: guillavoie



    Bandit King of Ancient China is an excellent Koei game, it isn't just a 'rare turd'.





    The games are apple to oranges, that much is obvious, but I don't know how anyone can say it's more entertaining than a Mega Man game, unless you specifically dislike the Mega Man style. And it certainly hasn't aged anywhere near as well as all of the Mega Man games. I wasn't saying it was awful, and they are very different games, but it's not like it's a game that most people will go back and play like they would a Mega Man game.
  • Mega man 5 is dropping? Since when?



    game value now shows its been at the same steady price for a year.
  • Originally posted by: quest4nes



    Mega man 5 is dropping? Since when?



    game value now shows its been at the same steady price for a year.



    That was my thought.

     
  • I never traded stuff in for new stuff as a kid. I saved money for my own new games or waited till christmas or my birthday. I never wanted to sell my old stuff. I always liked going back to it. I would have never even considered letting it go for the prices some of you did to gamestops etc.
  • Lucky for me I haven't made a bad trade since I started trading online back in 2010. Now, I have been scammed before by some trailer trash ginger down in Texas over on a Yugioh site (PM me if you want more info) but I never did any lopsided trades that were in the other parties favor but I'm not saying I wouldn't over-trade if it's something like Yugioh/MTG cards for games since I retired from both of those games long ago.
  • Last year I traded about $100 in NES games to a guy here with over 300 feedback for a RGB modded N64.

    I got the 64 and it was put together poorly where it was not even all the way together, and the RGB mod, and 64 did not even work. I ended up having to spend an additional 30 or $40 on a scart cable to test it, and in the end I ended up just counting it as a loss and I still have it somewhere. The guy had apparently bought it from someone on a Facebook page and had never tested it or make sure it worked and then traded it to me like that.



    Only time I've ever really been scammed on a game trade, and it was on this site with a completely legit member.
  • One time, I paid more than $30 for an NES game    
  • I traded to Electronics Boutique a crap load of CIB Genesis games plus a complete boxed 32X and CIB Knuckles Chaotix for Toy Story for the Genesis. I think it was like $17 total.
  • A while back I traded a spare copy of space megaforce for fire emblem on gamecube. At the time their prices were close but now not at all. Oh well. Traded to a buddy.
  • Just remembered mine! Original game boy, case, rechargeable battery and about 8 games, for a game gear with 1 game, no battery covers or box, and one side of the battery compartment was warped from fire.
  • I traded in a ton of top quality SNES games to a local pawn shop back in the early 2000's for like 50$.



    The funny part of that story is that one of the former owners of the pawn shop was selling games on Ebay a few years ago when I started collecting again and I likely bought my original copy of a CIB off him; after I paid he sent a message proclaiming he owned a shop in my home city that he was sending and it was a small world. We had a little back and forth message chat and he even claimed to remember the day I walked in like an idiot and left with 50$ for my stack of great games.



    Live and learn as they say!
Sign In or Register to comment.