Retro Gamers are Reminiscing About a JRPG that Never Existed

This is something I've always wondered about: Could someone realistically hoax a retro-game? It turns out two indie game-devs accidentally did just that. They created an indie game that recreates a Usenet board for a fictional PS1 JRPG called "Arc Symphony". To promote their game, they created mock-ups of the fictional game's jewel case:



From Kotaku:



"Sophia Park and Penelope Evans initially gave out jewel cases for Arc Symphony, a “classic” JRPG that they made up whole cloth, to their friends so that they would post about it on social media. Park and Evans brought the remaining cases to the Toronto Comic Arts Festival, and found that people wanted in on the fun, and that a few would insist to them that they’d actually played Arc Symphony.



“They saw one of our jewel cases and said ‘Oh. Yeah, I remember this. Didn’t dig into it much though,’” Park said over email. “We were both stunned.”



“One or two people at TCAF mentioned something along the lines of: oh, I think maybe I played this at a friend’s place,” Evans said. “That was surreal. I was really focused on nailing the look of the case, and apparently I succeeded.”



http://kotaku.com/people-are-reminiscing-about-a-ps1-jrpg-that-didnt-exis-1795227061



Bravo to them. The PS1 is probably the best system to pull off something like this: The library is huge and not as throughly covered by Youtubers like the NES/SNES.



 

Comments

  • A lot of poser hipsters out now-a-days
  • It does look like it could be a legit release. I don't know PS1, so if you showed it to me, I would've been none the wiser
  • Even just going by the cover art, this "Arc Symphony" game doesn't look overly convincing. I don't know of any other PS1 games that actually include Japanese text on a USA-released game, much less other languages. The cover artwork also looks a little too 90s cheesy to be real. A lot of PS1 games had boring or terrible artwork, but this game has that "trying too hard" element about it. Lastly, the black PlayStation banner on the left looks off, something not quite right about it. I think the font is a bit too thin.



    That said, this is certainly an interesting effort. Most people don't go to the lengths of faking demo discs and PSN digital downloads.
  • Originally posted by: Guntz



    Even just going by the cover art, this "Arc Symphony" game doesn't look overly convincing. I don't know of any other PS1 games that actually include Japanese text on a USA-released game, much less other languages. The cover artwork also looks a little too 90s cheesy to be real. A lot of PS1 games had boring or terrible artwork, but this game has that "trying too hard" element about it. Lastly, the black PlayStation banner on the left looks off, something not quite right about it. I think the font is a bit too thin.



    That said, this is certainly an interesting effort. Most people don't go to the lengths of faking demo discs and PSN digital downloads.





    Knowing for a fact that this is a pastiche, I agree with your observations regarding the cover. There is definitely something off about it, not just in the details, but as a whole... It basically looks TOO MUCH like the final fantasy covers of the time. This is fine at first glance, but doesn't really make sense... Why would a company have designed coverart that confuses their title with a very similar but vastly more popular game in the same genre?



    Of course, it is very easy for us to say this knowing the full story! If I had just seen that sitting on the shelf at my local gamestore it would simply be another PS title I glanced over before digging into the N64 games!
  • I could have told ya all it was bullshit  
  • It's convincing enough for the casual observer. Gotta remember that for the average gamer, they probably aren't stuck in the past like we are. Their memories of the 32-Bit RPG era are hazy from like 15 years of playing subsequent generations of games, and not being familiar with the entire freakin libraries of systems, this is probably one of dozens of games they're totally unaware of. If it were real, that is.
  • I feel like I see a PS1 game I've never heard of every time I walk into the game store. Put it next to Dragon Valor, Lucky Luke, and Silent Bomber and I'd totally believe you if you told me it was some obscure game no one talks about. They wouldn't be able to out me as a poser pretending to remember a game. Not knowing about Playstation is my specialty.
  • Originally posted by: MrWunderful



    A lot of poser hipsters out now-a-days





    Ya, you know, all the kids are into it, after all, nothing gets the ladies excited nowadays like pretending to remember a PlayStation One game that never existed. I think I saw it it Teen Vogue.
  • I stopped at kotaku.
  • Reminds me a lot of the artwork on Final Fantasy Tactics on PS1. I bet people were confusing it with that one.
  • Originally posted by: DefaultGen

    Not knowing about Playstation is my specialty.



    you and me both mang.
  • Originally posted by: jonebone



    Reminds me a lot of the artwork on Final Fantasy Tactics on PS1. I bet people were confusing it with that one.



    I was thinking the same thing.



     
  • These are the same hipster types that are driving up prices for us all and Kotaku's where they tend to hang out. These are the same 20 somethings that are driving up prices on vintage 80s clothes because it's fashionable now.
  • I actually see it as a pretty easy mistake to make.. It's not like those oldshool jrps are all that unique, you played one you played em all and the if the game was a japanese one the names aren't always consistently translated either  

  • Originally posted by: wesr



    These are the same hipster types that are driving up prices for us all and Kotaku's where they tend to hang out. These are the same 20 somethings that are driving up prices on vintage 80s clothes because it's fashionable now.



    Hey. Hey listen: we're all driving up the prices together.
  • Why would anyone even do this? It makes no sense.
  • As somebody who barely knows anything about PS1, could have fooled me if it was mixed in with some others. Not my specialty at all.

  • Originally posted by: Daria




    Originally posted by: wesr



    These are the same hipster types that are driving up prices for us all and Kotaku's where they tend to hang out. These are the same 20 somethings that are driving up prices on vintage 80s clothes because it's fashionable now.



    Hey. Hey listen: we're all driving up the prices together.







     It also doesn't help that you have shows like American Pickers pointing out that gaming stuff is becoming sought after and collectible, that just makes folks think everything is worth a fortune.



    What this does prove is how easily the mind and memory can be fooled by showing something that seems familiar your mind thinks it's something you played in the past. That said I didn't mean to offend and 20 somethings on here.
  • The name and artwork I'm guessing are kind of a mish-mash of three different PS1 games: Arc the Lad, Symphony of the Night, and Final Fantasy Tactics. It's likely that many are having false memories because they're vaguely remembering one of those particular games.
  • I saw a few people post this on Instagram and my eyebrow raised.

    IMO the cover art makes it look like a "How to Play the Piano" game.
  • Originally posted by: Kagemusha



    Why would anyone even do this? It makes no sense.



    Because it's fun and led to amusing results?



    Remember about a month or so ago when people "remembered" having seen a film with Sinbad called "Shazam"? I think this is someone's unoriginal attempt to do that in video game form.

     
  • Clearly the Mandela Effect....in Effect!
  • shows why people are so easily duped by fakes, that "case" insert is obviously fake, just a piece of paper stuck in a jewel case printed on photo paper. and it uses the wrong ESRB logo type /overanalyzingameme
  • The one thing these mock-ups always get wrong is the Japanese. Just pure Google Translate garbage. Looks convincing otherwise, though.
Sign In or Register to comment.