The History Channel flubs another one.

The History Channel recently ran a documentary supporting the theory that Amelia Earhart and Fred Noonan were secretly captured by the Japanese military.  The centerpiece of the show was a recently discovered photograph of a pier in the Marshall Islands (which were occupied by the Japanese at that time).   The photo is really blurry and shows two people who might be the aviators. There is also a barge with a blob that might be an airplane. 



http://www.cnn.com/2017/07/05/us/new-amelia-earhart-photo-trnd/index.html



It turns out the photo was taken in 1935 (or shortly before) and was published in a Japanese book in that year. The photo was digitized and put online in 2011 (if I am reading the site correctly).  



http://dl.ndl.go.jp/info:ndljp/pid/1223403/99?itemId=info:ndljp/pid/1223403&contentNo=99&__lang=en



I guess the yolk is on the History Channel's screen on this one.    
«1

Comments

  • Not too surprising. They're more interested in selling interesting narratives for ratings than broadcasting accurate history
  • What do you expect from a channel that airs Pawn Stars, Ice Road Truckers and UFO Hunters?
  • Originally posted by: Tulpa



    What do you expect from a channel that airs Pawn Stars, Ice Road Truckers and UFO Hunters?



    Not to mention Ancient Aliens. 

     
  • Originally posted by: Tulpa



    What do you expect from a channel that airs Pawn Stars, Ice Road Truckers and UFO Hunters?

    Came to say this lol It's TV. Almost no channel is spared these days from nonsense. 



     
  • The History channel has been a joke for quite some time. Definitely don't take anything they say as gospel...
  • I love this lol. Thanks for sharing OP
  • I remember a time where The History Channel made up probably 90% of my TV watching. Now it's about zero.
  • Researching history is hard. It's easier to just make shit up.
  • "Alternative history"
  • And sooner or later fake news (of any stripe) will become fake history. Winston Smith lives!
  • So the ancient aliens used their time machine to move her a few years earlier!
  • I feel like the word documentary has been used and abused more and more recently...
  • The history channel has lost all credibility years ago when it turned into reality shows full of white trash, mobster wannabes, and antique collectors who are unlikeable. Then they take away history international and make it H2 and now it's gone off our cable. The military history channel is available but it's on an extra tier. Everything discovery communications has bought in the last 20 years has gone to shit along with everything A&E's bought. I watch science channel and Smithsonian when i can but since they're digital only i can only see them in the living room. I just watch my documentaries on youtube or buy them from amazon cheap.

    PBS is just as bad with their stuff. The Ken Burns documentary on World War 2 claimed there was a race riot in my dad's home town outside Youngstown but nobody in the town or historical society remembered it so they had to do a retraction. It was actually just a labor dispute and not a race thing.
  • South Park episode about the History Channel and aliens is one of my favorites
  • I used to enjoy some of the alien specials but they're literally refilming and repackaging the same ones with new title sequences. I've seen the same show on 3 channels with 3 different show names.
  • I am entertained by the history channel. Tv is more fun if you don't take it so seriously.
  • It sounds like my students trying to fake an answer on the test and hoping I won't notice.
  • I miss the history channel. It is not at all what it used to be. I spent a lot of time gaming and watching all those random hour long documentaries during summer vacations.
  • That picture had everyone thinking it was real for a few days until it was debunked.
  • But it was on TV!? How "isn't" it true!
  • I used to love history channel when I was a kid. Modern Marvels, American Eats, the Halloween and Christmas specials, all great childhood memories. They really went to shit though back in the mid 2000's with all the "reality" garbage. They lasted just slightly longer then the discovery channel which took a nose dive with American Chopper. If anyone is interested though most of the Modern Marvel episodes are on youtube and the holiday specials are on dailymotion
  • It turns out they even mis-identified the boat in the background of the photo - hilarious
  • I actually do have this photo from 1938 though that shows what I'm quite certain is Amelia receiving a trust fall



  • Don't let the facts get in the way of a good story
  • I used to love stuff like Mail Call, Tales of the Gun, and Modern Marvels. I didn't even mind a few of the reality shows. I think top shot was ok, and early on some of the American pickers and pawn stars stuff was ok, but now that they've moved all the actual history to premium channels and flooded the main one with mostly bullshit its just another reason to not have cable anymore.
  • I enjoy watching some of the History channel shows but they have gone the way of MTV.

    More sensationalized reality shows which are worthless IMHO and less of the content that made them who they were. It doesn't matter if it is true, ratings and press coverage is what they are after. 
  • I love the new History Channel. /shrug
  • Small rant. Ignore if you're not in the mood:



    I am very much a capitalist who believes in free markets but this type of nonsense is what happens when publicly trade companies focus strictly on the bottomline. Today, you could create the most amazing, accurate History or Science channel, and if you have any moderate success, you will get acquired by one of the big content making companies. At that point, the pressure from corporate will come in to "expand" so that you can get more viewers and, thus, more ad revenue.



    Ever since the days of MTV (as already mentioned) the easiest way for a channel to make money is through reality TV. I don't know why but mass groups of people eat that stuff up. So your amazing, wonderful, truthful station will play a single reality TV show and your ratings will go "through the roof" for that hour. And, thus begins your channels downward spiral to crappiness.



    This has happened to awesome stations like MTV, VH1, Discovery, TLC, Family Channel (yes, I'll throw the ORIGINAL family channel in here), Nickelodeon, A&E and countless others.



    TL;DR: Reality TV is a soul killer for any station, but it's a guaranteed money maker. So far, I've yet to see a single, good station not succumb to this spiral. People love train wrecks or crafted stories that feel "real". So long as this is the stuff the masses want, every station will eventually start making this material in search of "cash cows".
  • I don't buy cable. I remember watching the history channel years ago and it was awesome. I was at someone's house and was flipping through the channels. I found ancient aliens. Ancient fucking aliens. Oh how the history channel has fallen.
  • Originally posted by: rlh



    TL;DR: Reality TV is a soul killer for any station, but it's a guaranteed money maker. So far, I've yet to see a single, good station not succumb to this spiral. People love train wrecks or crafted stories that feel "real". So long as this is the stuff the masses want, every station will eventually start making this material in search of "cash cows".



    The main reason stations put out reality TV is because they're very cheap & easy to create. Aside from the host, the cast are random fools (no need for actors) and everything they say/do is done on-the-fly (no need for writers). The shows aren't a guaranteed money maker, but they do serve as cheap filler for time slots networks don't want to invest resources in.

     
Sign In or Register to comment.