NES controller region lock?

Hi there.



I remember once having an NES PAL, i think it was from France or Spain and just specific controllers (those who came with it) worked with that console.

So my question is what was it that region locked those controllers? 



I was wondering about getting NES advantage and this just flew into my mind when i saw the cheapest one for me came from USA, if they were somehow region made.

Myself am located in Iceland so i am running on a PAL console

Comments

  • USA controllers will work on your console assuming it says "SCN" on the bottom of it.

    All controllers will work on USA and SCN (and Korean, and Asian, and Hong Kong, and Indian, etc.), however only European controllers will work on European consols.
  • My console is SCN so all controllers work on that. Great too know. Thanks!
  • For SNES controllers there is a resistor in a different position on the PCB which can be moved. The PCB is even labeled. The controller block in the console also had a resistor that could be changed to make it accept all controllers. The NES and SNES controllers are electrically the same even though they don't physically fit and the SNES has more buttons (this is why passive NES to SNES and SNES to NES cable adapters work).



    I don't recall ever seeing a label on the NES controller PCB but if that part works the same as SNES it should be easy to find on an NES controller.
  • Insane some of the things you learn around here, I had absolutely no idea that there was any kind of region locking on controllers whatsoever! Cool and valuable info, for sure, especially as a PAL gamer myself...



    One small spanner I would like to throw into the works, however... I often use the dogbone controller from my AV Famicom with my PAL NES, and it works fine. Anyone have any idea why this might be the case?
  • Originally posted by: CZroe



    For SNES controllers there is a resistor in a different position on the PCB which can be moved. The PCB is even labeled. The controller block in the console also had a resistor that could be changed to make it accept all controllers. The NES and SNES controllers are electrically the same even though they don't physically fit and the SNES has more buttons (this is why passive NES to SNES and SNES to NES cable adapters work).



    I don't recall ever seeing a label on the NES controller PCB but if that part works the same as SNES it should be easy to find on an NES controller.



    So does the controller not work at all unless you change the position on the PCB?

     
  • Originally posted by: OptOut



    Insane some of the things you learn around here, I had absolutely no idea that there was any kind of region locking on controllers whatsoever! Cool and valuable info, for sure, especially as a PAL gamer myself...



    One small spanner I would like to throw into the works, however... I often use the dogbone controller from my AV Famicom with my PAL NES, and it works fine. Anyone have any idea why this might be the case?





    what is the code on the bottom of the controller, and what is the (country) code on the bottom of the NES?
  • Originally posted by: OptOut



    Insane some of the things you learn around here, I had absolutely no idea that there was any kind of region locking on controllers whatsoever! Cool and valuable info, for sure, especially as a PAL gamer myself...



    One small spanner I would like to throw into the works, however... I often use the dogbone controller from my AV Famicom with my PAL NES, and it works fine. Anyone have any idea why this might be the case?



    They removed the CIC (or "NES10" copy protection chip) in the NES-101 to save costs, so maybe universally-compatible controllers was also a cost-cutting measure to streamline manufacturing the boards.

     
  • If it says NES-004E on the back, it will work with all consoles.



    If it says NES-004 it will only work with SCN and NTSC consoles.



    There are two available "fixes" if need be - One is to add a resistor to the controller, making it usable on all systems, another is to solder between the points behind the controller input on the console itself, making the console accept all controllers.
  • Originally posted by: tordur



    If it says NES-004E on the back, it will work with all consoles.



    If it says NES-004 it will only work with SCN and NTSC consoles.



    There are two available "fixes" if need be - One is to add a resistor to the controller, making it usable on all systems, another is to solder between the points behind the controller input on the console itself, making the console accept all controllers.



    very interesting topic.



  • I remember having some issues with controllers until I realised this quirk. I was wondering why NTSC controllers didn't work on my PAL system.

    I have no idea why SCN consoles aren't region locked though... You guys sure got all the good stuff as far as PAL stuff goes  
  • Originally posted by: Vectrex28



    I have no idea why SCN consoles aren't region locked though... You guys sure got all the good stuff as far as PAL stuff goes  

    Aye, there are a few neat items only available in SCN  



    In regards to the controllers, Bergsala, the Swedish-based Scandinavian distributor, got rights to distibute NES consoles in Scandinavia before the rest of Europe got onboard, which is why all the low-serial number PAL-B consoles come from Scandinavia.



    The theory is, that the other distributors, which came later, wanted some kind of secury measures to prevent parallel-import, which is why Nintendo made the lock on the controllers - Bergsala didn't have this mindset, when they started out before everybody else in Europe, so the theory goes that Nintendo never saw the need for changing the controller specs before the other distributors voiced their concern.







     
  • Originally posted by: M3CHK1LLA

    very interesting topic.



  • Originally posted by: Of games


    what is the code on the bottom of the controller, and what is the (country) code on the bottom of the NES?





    My NES is a UK model, PAL A. I think its a later one, but not quite sure. As for the controller, it says HVC 102, as you can see in the pics below (also check out the tiny cord length, lol!). Does anyone know what the model number of the US or the Australian dogbone controller are?
  • It's a nice idea that they made the controller not work for each region, however in reality it was so they could get RFI certification. Asia uses the USA/scn style too. If they really wanted distinction, they would have set up restrictions between pal-a and pal-b(since the Mattel NES was supposed to be an "exclusive Mattel system". SCN uses the USA type because Nintendo pushed the product too fast to realize it wouldn't pass RFI testing, and they couldn't easily backport everything without having to recall all consoles.



    No clue why the famicom works on the uk Nes, perhaps the circuit works on both.. idunno, you'd have to open it for reading of the circuit.
  • Originally posted by: OptOut

     
    Originally posted by: Of games



    what is the code on the bottom of the controller, and what is the (country) code on the bottom of the NES?







    My NES is a UK model, PAL A. I think its a later one, but not quite sure. As for the controller, it says HVC 102, as you can see in the pics below (also check out the tiny cord length, lol!). Does anyone know what the model number of the US or the Australian dogbone controller are?





    NES-039 is dogbone, just like HVC-101 with longer cord and different markings on the back half. Not sure about PAL compatibility. I have no problems using both on my NES-001 or NES-101.
  • NES-039 is the same for the Australian one. I haven't tried it on a non-PAL(excl. SCN) console, but if it does work, I guess they figured out some circuitry to make it work on both types of consoles.
  • I actually had trouble when i started collecting as i bought one here in iceland and not knowing the console was from holland, i think, and only accepted controllets that had letters e last.. 004e.. other controllers where wonky except when using power controllers like max, bone controller etc.  
  • I'm not disputing anything in this thread, but my PAL SNES controllers that came in the German SNES work on US consoles (SNSP-005) I might try them on my Japan and Korean console after I move into my new home and report back.



    The only region locked controllers i've come into is the Japan N64 controllers will not work on the US console, which is weird since the games will....
Sign In or Register to comment.