Do I really need to play every other Zelda game?
So, I finished Link's Awakening about 6 months ago and I LOVE this game, so naturally you'd think that you'd want play the rest. But nope. The more I look at the games i could play and the games that are out there, the formula seems extremely repetative, so why do I need to play the same game, in 20 different versions?
Link's Awakening was a masterpiece of simplicity, discovery and everything I liked about Zelda. I feel similarly about Star Wars (the new movies). I like most people saw The Force Awakens and loved it for the nostalgia, but every other Star Wars Movie after the orginal 3, just seems labarious and stupid to me.
What's the point of re-hashing the same old formula over and over again. So it's link's awakening for me and I'm out.
Link's Awakening was a masterpiece of simplicity, discovery and everything I liked about Zelda. I feel similarly about Star Wars (the new movies). I like most people saw The Force Awakens and loved it for the nostalgia, but every other Star Wars Movie after the orginal 3, just seems labarious and stupid to me.
What's the point of re-hashing the same old formula over and over again. So it's link's awakening for me and I'm out.
Comments
I know people have wrong opinions on the internet, but this takes the cake!
Plus one on this.
WRONG!
I think they're all worth playing if you really like one of the entries tho I understand the desire to just really enjoy a game in a series and leave it at that
If you liked Link's Awakening try another one, any of them really. If you don't like it don't play it. I'm a huge fan of the series but there are some I don't really care for but the puzzle mechanics and the exploring mechanics are always top notch and different from game to to game. I would agree with BOTW being just the top tier game with A Link to the Past and Ocarina of Time right below it.
Its your precious time on Earth though, I’m just saying you need to play each one to realize there is something unique about each even though the equation is really the same. Have you ever played more than one Mario game?
Zelda 1 and BotW are the only 2 that are open-wprld. The rest are fairly linear.
The 4 swords games are fun but the hardware to set them up are too much of a barrier of entry for most.
Other than that the main difference is if you prefer 3D vs top-down and each game has it's own unique mechanic to make it different enough to enjoy. Except the 2 DS games. Those are garbage
Zelda 2 is my favorite game of all time and different from the others
Zelda 1 and BotW are the only 2 that are open-wprld. The rest are fairly linear.
The 4 swords games are fun but the hardware to set them up are too much of a barrier of entry for most.
Other than that the main difference is if you prefer 3D vs top-down and each game has it's own unique mechanic to make it different enough to enjoy. Except the 2 DS games. Those are garbage
Interesting that you like Zelda 2 but not phantom hourglass. I thought phantom hourglass was good, not great. Never did play spirit tracks. What makes Zelda 2 your all time favorite game of any game?
Zelda 2 is my favorite game of all time and different from the others
Zelda 1 and BotW are the only 2 that are open-wprld. The rest are fairly linear.
The 4 swords games are fun but the hardware to set them up are too much of a barrier of entry for most.
Other than that the main difference is if you prefer 3D vs top-down and each game has it's own unique mechanic to make it different enough to enjoy. Except the 2 DS games. Those are garbage
Interesting that you like Zelda 2 but not phantom hourglass. I thought phantom hourglass was good, not great. Never did play spirit tracks. What makes Zelda 2 your all time favorite game of any game?
What a strange comparison to make.
Zelda 2, while unconventional compared to the other games, has tight button based controls, and every level is a new experience and layout.
Phantom Hourglass is an exercise in misery with horrendous controls and a repetitive main level that is repeated way too frequently.
If phantom Hourglass had better controls it might have been more fun. But other than "being different" from mainline games, there is no comparison to make with Zelda 2 (and when Zelda 2 was made it was its own thing with no real pressure to not try something new and different while they built the series -- it is only in retrospect that it seems out of place at all)
The last Zelda I played and finished was Wind Waker on GameCube. Bloody good fun! Alas, no time to play out the modern versions of Zelda, apart from several hours of game time on Twilight Princess and Phantom Hourglass.
Though if you're genuinely a gamer and genuinely liking a game, the OP is basically saying "if I've played 1 Mario, Sonic, Grand Theft Auto, Devil May Cry, then I don't need to play any of the other prequels or sequels!"
That's like saying "all RPGs are the same anyway, so why play more than 1 RPG?"
Zelda 2 is my favorite game of all time and different from the others
Zelda 1 and BotW are the only 2 that are open-wprld. The rest are fairly linear.
The 4 swords games are fun but the hardware to set them up are too much of a barrier of entry for most.
Other than that the main difference is if you prefer 3D vs top-down and each game has it's own unique mechanic to make it different enough to enjoy. Except the 2 DS games. Those are garbage
Interesting that you like Zelda 2 but not phantom hourglass. I thought phantom hourglass was good, not great. Never did play spirit tracks. What makes Zelda 2 your all time favorite game of any game?
What a strange comparison to make.
Zelda 2, while unconventional compared to the other games, has tight button based controls, and every level is a new experience and layout.
Phantom Hourglass is an exercise in misery with horrendous controls and a repetitive main level that is repeated way too frequently.
If phantom Hourglass had better controls it might have been more fun. But other than "being different" from mainline games, there is no comparison to make with Zelda 2 (and when Zelda 2 was made it was its own thing with no real pressure to not try something new and different while they built the series -- it is only in retrospect that it seems out of place at all)
Surprised there's so much hate for phantom hourglass. It really wasn't THAT bad. If you want real bad controls, try kid Icarus uprising on the 3ds.
And I was comparing his favorite to his least favorite. Not a weird comparison at all.
I think it's a fair call to the OP if you have limited time, then nothing wrong with trying different games/franchise. I particularly find I have no interest in RPGs these days simply because I don't have the time, what with work and family commitments etc.
The last Zelda I played and finished was Wind Waker on GameCube. Bloody good fun! Alas, no time to play out the modern versions of Zelda, apart from several hours of game time on Twilight Princess and Phantom Hourglass.
Though if you're genuinely a gamer and genuinely liking a game, the OP is basically saying "if I've played 1 Mario, Sonic, Grand Theft Auto, Devil May Cry, then I don't need to play any of the other prequels or sequels!"
That's like saying "all RPGs are the same anyway, so why play more than 1 RPG?"
Many of them are to me. If people are honest, BOTW is the same zelda formula, but in 3d and expansive. Mario is a little different for me, because with platformers, pretty much everything is different. The level designs and the mechanics can have a drastic affect on game play, so I'm not bored. But zelda and many rpgs are just very silimar. Zelda you basically look for keys defeat enemies, find the nightmare key, rince and repeat. Sure the puzzles are different, but not drastically. Zelda has a great formula, but once you play one version of that formula you've played them all.
That is why I am more interested in playing Adventures of Link, since it devianted from that formula.
I know people have wrong opinions on the internet, but this takes the cake!
Haha so true I started with ocarina which some consider the best! I’ve since finished a link to the past and I’m in the last dungeon on the first nes game id go so far to say all Zelda games should at least once
I feel like this is a troll thread.
I started thinking the same thing after I posted. The "re-hashing the same formula over and over again" line is basically a satire of any game that there is more than one of in a series lol
I feel like this is a troll thread.
I started thinking the same thing after I posted. The "re-hashing the same formula over and over again" line is basically a satire of any game that there is more than one of in a series lol
Why would I play Street Fighter 5 if I've already played the original Mortal Kombat on SNES? Talk about a rehash!
That is why I am more interested in playing Adventures of Link, since it devianted from that formula.
You'd love Majora's Mask.
I feel like this is a troll thread.
I was framed I tells ye! ...oh, wait.
Try Majora's Mask, it really changes up the gameplay with the three day mechanic. Or BotW as others have mentioned. If you liked the style of LA, I also insist you try A Link Between Worlds, its one of the Top 5 Zeldas, IMO.
He claims BotW is "the same Zelda formula". You're being trolled.