A certain N64 CIB that I found while out and about...
...that being Transformers: Beast Wars. The box is in fair shape, some creases/bends and one small rip at the top, with a Blockbuster sticker covering the UPC on the back (that, btw, might be removable), about 6.5-7/10; the cartridge has two stickers (albeit mostly clear, with the exception of "Property of Blockbuster" on the front and a metal strip on the back) completely covering the front and back label and is otherwise in great shape (9/10); and the manual has a crease on the upper-right corners of the front cover and first couple pages, but is otherwise in great shape (8/10). I heard this one was kinda rare...I'd believe I was correct in making that statement, but how much is it worth these days?
Comments
http://cgi.ebay.com/Transformers-Beast-Wars-Transmetals-N64-game-and-box_W0QQitemZ110510072813QQcmdZViewItemQQptZVideo_Games_Games?hash=item19bae9e3ed
Obviously I think that is quite low, but it still shows a weak demand. You don't see CIBs very often, last one I saw was a seller in UK asking $80 BIN for a very well conditioned copy but it didn't sell.
So having said all of that, I'd guess $40-$50.
http://nintendoage.com/index.cfm?FuseAction=N64.View&egID=10539&lgID=10539